Guide
Why breakups hurt: what the research shows
Breakups hurt partly because romantic rejection engages brain systems involved in reward, craving and distress, and because a relationship becomes part of how people define themselves. Long-term studies find that breakups are followed on average by a small but measurable rise in distress and drop in life satisfaction, with wide differences between people. Studies that follow people over time find that symptoms ease for many but not all, and there is no fixed recovery timeline.
Rejection and physical pain
The idea that rejection "hurts" has been tested with brain imaging. In a 2011 study, 40 adults who had gone through an unwanted breakup in the previous six months viewed a photo of their former partner while thinking about the rejection, and separately received painful heat. Both experiences activated regions linked to the emotional side of pain, and also the secondary somatosensory cortex and dorsal posterior insula, regions linked to its sensory side (Kross et al., 2011).
Later work complicates this picture. A 2014 reanalysis that included those participants and 20 more used pattern-based methods and found that physical pain and social rejection produced distinct activity patterns, even within shared regions. The authors concluded that rejection does not simply reuse the brain's pain code (Woo et al., 2014). The two experiences overlap in where they occur in the brain, but they are not identical.
Reward, craving and longing
A second line of research looks at why people keep thinking about a former partner. In a study of 15 people who had been rejected an average of 63 days earlier and still reported being intensely in love, viewing a photo of the former partner activated the ventral tegmental area, ventral striatum and orbitofrontal cortex. These regions are associated with motivation, reward and craving, and some overlap with those active in cocaine craving (Fisher et al., 2010).
The authors suggested this may help explain the obsessive thinking that can follow rejection. The study also found that more days since the rejection were associated with less activity in a region linked to attachment, which the authors interpreted as possible evidence that time helps. With 15 participants, these results are preliminary.
Effects on identity and self-concept
Couples develop shared friends, routines and, to some degree, shared identities. Across three studies, Slotter, Gardner and Finkel (2010) found that after a breakup people reported changes in the content of their self-concept and reduced self-concept clarity, a less certain sense of who they are. Reduced clarity uniquely predicted emotional distress after the breakup.
This helps explain why a breakup can feel like losing part of oneself, not only losing a partner.
Effects on mental health
A study of 1,295 unmarried adults aged 18 to 35, surveyed every four months for 20 months, compared each person's wellbeing before and after a breakup. On average, psychological distress rose and life satisfaction fell, each by an effect size of d = 0.24, which the authors describe as small but not trivial. About 43% of breakups were followed by a decline larger than half a standard deviation in at least one of the two measures. Declines in life satisfaction were larger for couples who had lived together or had plans to marry, and smaller for people who had started dating someone new (Rhoades et al., 2011).
| Study | Sample | Main finding |
|---|---|---|
| Rhoades et al., 2011 | 1,295 unmarried adults, 20 months | Distress up and life satisfaction down after a breakup (d = 0.24 each) |
| Verhallen et al., 2022 | 87 women, 30 weeks after a breakup | Four trajectories: 38 resilient, 22 fast recovery, 19 slow recovery, 8 chronic distress |
| Lewandowski and Bizzoco, 2007 | 155 undergraduates after a recent breakup | Growth linked to leaving a relationship low in self-expansion; mediated by rediscovering the self and positive emotions |
How recovery unfolds over time
Research does not support a single recovery timeline. In a study of 87 young women in the Netherlands who had gone through a breakup within the previous two months, depressive symptoms were measured every two weeks for 30 weeks. Four patterns emerged: 38 women had low symptoms throughout, 22 recovered quickly, 19 recovered slowly, and 8 had symptoms that stayed high, on average above a clinical cut-off. The chronic group reported more brooding rumination than the resilient group (Verhallen et al., 2022).
Some people also report growth. Lewandowski and Bizzoco (2007) surveyed 155 undergraduates who had recently ended a relationship and found that growth was linked to leaving a relationship that offered little self-expansion, through rediscovering the self, less loss of self and more positive emotions. In the first author's own summary, about 41% rated their breakup as positive overall and 33% as negative. The study measured people at one point in time and did not measure how long recovery takes; figures sometimes attributed to it, such as a set number of weeks to recover, do not appear in its published abstract or in that summary.
What tends to help
Evidence on specific strategies is limited and mixed. Expressive writing, a method developed by James Pennebaker in which people write about their deepest thoughts and feelings, typically for 20 minutes on 4 consecutive days, has a small but reliable positive effect across meta-analyses and has been used after non-marital breakups (as summarised by Sbarra et al., 2013).
It does not suit everyone at every stage. In a randomised study of 90 recently separated adults, people who were actively searching for meaning in their separation did worse up to nine months later when assigned to expressive writing than when assigned to neutral writing. The authors suggest that writing in depth while an experience is still raw can intensify distress (Sbarra et al., 2013).
Relationships with other people also appear to matter: in the 20-month study, people who had started dating someone new showed smaller declines in life satisfaction, though this is an association, not proof of cause (Rhoades et al., 2011). If low mood persists or worsens, speaking with a doctor or mental health professional is appropriate.
This article is general information, not medical or psychological advice; anyone thinking about self-harm should contact a local crisis line or emergency number.
Frequently asked questions
Is breakup pain the same as physical pain?
Not exactly. A 2011 fMRI study found that rejection and physical pain activated overlapping brain regions, but a 2014 reanalysis with a larger sample found that the two produced distinct activity patterns. They overlap but are not identical.
How long does it take to get over a breakup?
There is no fixed timeline. In a 30-week study of 87 women, most had low symptoms or recovered during the study, while 8 had symptoms that stayed high. Recovery speed varied widely between people.
Why can't I stop thinking about my ex?
Brain-imaging research suggests that romantic rejection engages systems linked to reward, motivation and craving, which may help explain persistent longing. Repetitive brooding has been associated with slower recovery from depressive symptoms after a breakup.
Does writing about a breakup help?
It can, on average, but not for everyone. Expressive writing shows small positive effects across studies, yet one randomised trial found it was associated with worse outcomes for separated adults who were actively searching for meaning in what had happened.
Sources
- Kross, Berman, Mischel, Smith & Wager (2011). Social rejection shares somatosensory representations with physical pain. PNAS 108(15), 6270-6275. — 40 adults after an unwanted breakup; rejection and physical pain activated overlapping regions, including sensory pain regions.
- Woo, Koban, Kross, Lindquist, Banich, Ruzic, Andrews-Hanna & Wager (2014). Separate neural representations for physical pain and social rejection. Nature Communications 5, 5380. — Reanalysis with 60 participants; multivariate patterns for pain and rejection were distinct.
- Rutgers University. Study finds romantic rejection stimulates areas of the brain involved in motivation, reward and addiction (on Fisher, Brown, Aron, Strong & Mashek, Journal of Neurophysiology, 2010). — 15 recently rejected participants; reward and craving regions active; time since rejection associated with less activity in an attachment-related region.
- ScienceDaily, materials provided by SAGE Publications (2010). On Slotter, Gardner & Finkel, Who am I without you? The influence of romantic breakup on the self-concept. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 36(2), 147-160. — Three studies; breakups associated with self-concept change and reduced self-concept clarity, which predicted distress.
- Rhoades, Kamp Dush, Atkins, Stanley & Markman (2011). Breaking up is hard to do: the impact of unmarried relationship dissolution on mental health and life satisfaction. Journal of Family Psychology 25(3), 366-374. — 1,295 adults over 20 months; distress up and life satisfaction down after breakups (d = 0.24); moderators of life-satisfaction decline.
- Verhallen, Alonso-Martinez, Renken, Marsman & ter Horst (2022). Depressive symptom trajectory following romantic relationship breakup and effects of rumination, neuroticism and cognitive control. Stress and Health 38(4), 653-665. — 87 women over 30 weeks; four recovery trajectories; brooding higher in the chronic-distress group.
- Lewandowski (2022). A breakup doesn't have to leave you broken. Psychology Today (first author's summary of Lewandowski & Bizzoco, Journal of Positive Psychology 2(1), 40-54, 2007). — About 41% rated their breakup positive overall and 33% negative; growth after leaving low self-expansion relationships; no recovery timeline reported.
- Sbarra, Boals, Mason, Larson & Mehl (2013). Expressive writing can impede emotional recovery following marital separation. Clinical Psychological Science 1(2), 120-134. — Summarises the expressive writing paradigm and its small positive meta-analytic effect; randomised trial of 90 separated adults found worse outcomes for those searching for meaning.