Guide
Attachment styles after a breakup
Adult attachment research describes how people think, feel and act in close relationships along two dimensions, attachment anxiety and attachment avoidance. Studies link higher anxiety to more preoccupation and distress after a breakup and higher avoidance to distancing, self-reliant coping. These are average tendencies on continuous scales rather than fixed types, and a short quiz cannot reliably place a person on them.
What attachment styles are
Attachment theory was developed by John Bowlby, Mary Ainsworth and others to explain the bonds infants form with caregivers. In 1987, Cindy Hazan and Phillip Shaver proposed that adult romantic love is also an attachment process. They translated the three infant categories, secure, avoidant and anxious/ambivalent, into descriptions of adult relationships, and two questionnaire studies found that adults in each category described their experience of love in predictably different ways.
Later work moved from categories to dimensions. Brennan, Clark and Shaver (1998) developed the Experiences in Close Relationships (ECR) questionnaire, which measures two continuous dimensions. Attachment-related anxiety reflects how insecure a person is about a partner's availability and responsiveness. Attachment-related avoidance reflects how uncomfortable a person is with closeness and with depending on others. Security corresponds to low scores on both. Taxometric analyses suggest that variation in attachment is best described by these dimensions rather than by distinct types.
How attachment relates to breakup distress
Davis, Shaver and Vernon (2003) surveyed more than 5,000 internet respondents. Attachment anxiety was associated with greater preoccupation with the lost partner, more extreme physical and emotional distress, stronger attempts to re-establish the relationship, angry or vengeful behavior and coping strategies the authors classified as dysfunctional. Attachment avoidance was weakly and negatively associated with most distress reactions and strongly associated with avoidant, self-reliant coping. Lower scores on both dimensions were associated with turning to friends and family for support. Insecurity, particularly anxiety, was associated with using alcohol and drugs to cope.
Sbarra (2006) followed 58 young adults with daily emotion reports for 4 weeks after the end of a serious relationship. Attachment preoccupation, along with ongoing love and anger, was associated with a lower probability of recovering from sadness during the study, while attachment security was associated with a higher probability of recovering from anger. Acceptance of the breakup accounted for the link between security and sadness recovery.
Distress is not the whole picture. In two studies of 411 and 465 people, Marshall, Bejanyan and Ferenczi (2013) found that attachment anxiety was indirectly linked to more personal growth after a breakup, through heightened distress, which was in turn linked to more reflection and brooding, whereas avoidance was indirectly linked to less growth, through suppressed distress. The authors described the distress of anxious individuals as hyperactivated and that of avoidant individuals as deactivated, terms used in attachment research for amplifying versus damping attachment-related emotion. They noted that their ratings were retrospective and their design cross-sectional.
| Dimension | Associated reactions | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Higher anxiety | Preoccupation with the ex, more distress, attempts to reconnect, slower sadness recovery | Davis et al., 2003; Sbarra, 2006 |
| Higher avoidance | Less reported distress, self-reliant coping, less personal growth | Davis et al., 2003; Marshall et al., 2013 |
| Low on both (secure) | Seeking support from friends and family, faster anger recovery | Davis et al., 2003; Sbarra, 2006 |
Why short online quizzes are not diagnostic
Research instruments are validated, meaning their reliability and their relationship to other measures have been tested in samples of participants. The revised version of the ECR (ECR-R), published by Fraley, Waller and Brennan in 2000, has 36 items, 18 for anxiety and 18 for avoidance, and produces two continuous scores. Validated short forms also exist; a 12-item ECR short form was tested across 6 studies against the original. What matters is validation, not only length.
Several points limit what a brief quiz can say. First, the developer of the ECR-R strongly recommends against sorting people into types based on their scores, noting that there are no natural cut-off points between categories. Second, the ECR-R is presented as a research measure of individual differences and does not provide clinical cut-offs. Third, attachment ratings fluctuate around a stable tendency over days and weeks, so answers given shortly after a breakup may partly reflect the current situation. An informal result is best treated as a prompt for reflection rather than a label.
Attachment patterns can change
Attachment is relatively stable but not fixed. Fraley and colleagues (2011) measured attachment daily for 30 days in 203 adults and weekly for a year in 388 adults, and found that the data fit a model with a stable underlying factor plus meaningful fluctuation around it. Chopik, Edelstein and Grimm (2019), combining longitudinal samples totaling 628 people from age 13 to 72, found that attachment anxiety declined on average with age, particularly in middle and older adulthood, and avoidance declined steadily across the lifespan. Being in a relationship predicted lower levels of both. These are average trends; individual paths vary.
No Contact: Closure's onboarding includes an informal three-question attachment-style quiz (anxious, avoidant or secure-leaning) that is explicitly not a diagnosis and only shapes how its scripted coach responds. This article is general information, not medical or psychological advice; anyone thinking about self-harm should contact a local crisis line or emergency number.
Frequently asked questions
What are the main attachment styles in adults?
Early research used three categories: secure, avoidant and anxious/ambivalent. Most researchers now measure two continuous dimensions, attachment anxiety and attachment avoidance, with security corresponding to low scores on both.
Do anxiously attached people take breakups harder?
On average, studies link higher attachment anxiety to more preoccupation with the former partner, more distress and slower recovery from sadness. These are group-level associations and do not predict any one person's experience.
Can an online quiz tell me my attachment style?
A short, unvalidated quiz cannot reliably measure attachment. Validated research questionnaires such as the 36-item ECR-R produce continuous scores, and their developers advise against sorting people into fixed types.
Can attachment style change?
Longitudinal studies suggest attachment is relatively stable but changes over time. On average, anxiety and avoidance decline with age, and being in a relationship is associated with lower levels of both.
Sources
- Hazan C, Shaver P (1987). Romantic love conceptualized as an attachment process. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 52(3):511-524 — PubMed abstract: origin of adult attachment styles in romantic relationships
- Fraley RC. Information on the Experiences in Close Relationships-Revised (ECR-R) adult attachment questionnaire. University of Illinois — 36 items (18 per dimension), definitions of anxiety and avoidance, origin in Brennan, Clark and Shaver (1998), recommendation against categorizing
- Davis D, Shaver PR, Vernon ML (2003). Physical, emotional, and behavioral reactions to breaking up. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 29(7):871-884 — PubMed abstract: survey of more than 5,000 respondents on attachment and breakup reactions
- Sbarra DA (2006). Predicting the onset of emotional recovery following nonmarital relationship dissolution. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 32(3):298-312 — PubMed abstract: 58 young adults, daily data for 4 weeks; attachment and sadness and anger recovery
- Marshall TC, Bejanyan K, Ferenczi N (2013). Attachment styles and personal growth following romantic breakups. PLoS ONE 8(9):e75161 — Two studies (N = 411, 465); anxiety and avoidance, distress and personal growth; stated limitations
- Wei M, Russell DW, Mallinckrodt B, Vogel DL (2007). The Experiences in Close Relationship Scale (ECR)-short form. Journal of Personality Assessment 88(2):187-204 — PubMed abstract: 12-item short form validated across 6 studies
- Fraley RC, Vicary AM, Brumbaugh CC, Roisman GI (2011). Patterns of stability in adult attachment. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 101(5):974-992 — PubMed abstract: daily and weekly measurement; stable factor with temporary variation
- Chopik WJ, Edelstein RS, Grimm KJ (2019). Longitudinal changes in attachment orientation over a 59-year period. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 116(4):598-611 — PubMed abstract: N = 628, ages 13-72; anxiety and avoidance decline on average with age